NCAA: Refs should have reviewed final play

Despite loss, Sycamores pleased with play at EIU

November 30, 2001

By Mark Bennett

Terence Avery didn't want to endure another second-half collapse.

Before Wednesday night's game at Eastern Illinois, Avery and the Indiana State Sycamores got overwhelmed in the final 20 minutes of losses to Illinois-Chicago, Valparaiso and Butler. As they returned to the visitors' lockerroom in Lantz Arena on Wednesday, the Sycamores trailed host EIU 26-19.

Avery made sure they remembered those first three games.

"In the lockerroom, I just told the guys that in the last three games we got depressed at halftime and came out and just had no effort. And I said tonight it's going to change; we're going to come out and play like we can play," Avery explained later. "And we did that. The guys made big plays down the stretch, and we were a team again. I'm disappointed we lost."

Indeed, the Sycamores did lose, 52-50 on a whirlwind final play and fell to 0-4. With the score tied 50-50, ISU senior Djibril Kante caught a pass from freshman teammate Lamar Grimes and attempted a short layup with eight seconds to play. Kante's shot, though, was blocked by Eastern Illinois star Henry Domercant. Domercant grabbed the rebound, passed to guard Craig Lewis, who dribbled downcourt and threw the basketball to Jesse Mackinson for the game-winning layup as the buzzer sounded.

ISU Coach Royce Waltman wanted officials to review the final play on television screens from a WTWO broadcast to make sure Mackinson's shot fell before the buzzer and to determine whether time remained afterward for a final play by the Sycamores. The referee crew of Brett Miles, Jeb Hartness and Joe Ward-Wallace never did review the play. WTWO replays appeared to show three-tenths of a second remained after Mackinson's basket.

As Waltman contended, officials are obliged to review a buzzer-beater shot at a televised game, said Marty Benson, the NCAA liaison to the men's basketball rules committee. That rule -- No. 2-5.2 on Page 32 of the NCAA handbook -- was adopted at midseason of the 1999-2000 season.

"Regardless of whether someone protests, the proper procedure is for the officials to go to look at the [television] monitor and make the decision. That is the rule," Benson said Thursday afternoon. "Of course, that doesn't guarantee that everybody is going to follow it."

Regardless, the Sycamores lost for the fourth straight time, with Saturday's 2:05 p.m. game in Hulman Center against IUPUI looming next.

There were some promising developments Wednesday. Avery scored a career-high 29 points and matched his best rebounding game with 12. He hit 11 of 18 field goals and 7 of 8 free throws, after sitting out the game's first five minutes. The Sycamores also held EIU to 37 percent field goal shooting, and outrebounded the Panthers 40-31.

 

Tribune-Star/Joseph C. Garza
Good job: Eastern Illinois center Jesse Mackinson (left) is congratulated by teammate Todd Bergmann after Mackinson made a last-second shot Tuesday night to defeat Indiana State in Lantz Gym at Charleston, Ill.

Waltman used a new lineup, with senior Kelyn Block, sophomore Marcus Howard and freshman Lamar Grimes at guards, Kante at center and freshman Jake Sams at forward. Sams had scored 13 points in Sunday's loss at Butler. At Charleston, though, Avery was the only Sycamore to score more than eight points. The rest of the team was 8 for 38 from the field (21 percent). Sams had four points and three rebounds in 10 minutes.

Eventually, Kante and Avery were playing together as they had as starters in the first three games.

"One of the problems is a lack of consistency, not in the team but in individuals," Waltman said. "Jake played in a way over at Butler that he earned the start, but did not really come out ready to go tonight. On the other hand, we've not won with Terence and Djibril in there together, but those two guys played with a lot of energy and fight tonight. But somebody's got to start playing with some consistency so we know who in the heck it is we are supposed to have in there."

Avery's numbers raised his averages to team-highs of 15 points and seven rebounds per game. He's ready to play in whatever role necessary, he said, but enjoys being in tandem with Kante.

"I'm hoping we can play together in there," the 6-foot-9, 240-pound Avery said of his 6-8, 245-pound teammate. "I just want to help the team win."

And Wednesday's comeback from a halftime deficit offered some hope.

"They actually made some plays down the stretch," Waltman said. "Clearly, we were one play short. But if we would compete like that and have the courage to make some plays, we'll have a chance."

   
   

Tribune-Star Copyright (c) 2001